According to Inventory of the Church Archives of New York City: Presbyterian Churches (New York, NY: Historical Records Survey, 1940), First German Presbyterian Church, New York, New York, was organized in 1852 and dissolved in 1872. Services were held at 91 Rivington Street, Manhattan. 

Records from the church deposited with us include:

First German Presbyterian Church, Manhattan, NY

• Register of Baptisms, 1852–1872, 3 vols. (Call number: Vault MI46 N48ezb)
• Register of Marriages, 1852–1872,  2 vols. (Call number: Vault MI46 N48ezm)